Penetrating and Explosive Injury Patterns



Penetrating and Explosive Injury Patterns


Ian S. Wedmore

John G. McManus Jr.

Timothy A. Coakley





INTRODUCTION

In the 21st century, it is an unfortunate fact that individuals on an expedition could become victims of penetrating or explosive trauma caused by accidents from hunting occurring nearby, becoming inadvertently shot while being caught up in political turmoil, or involved in an explosive event that is not uncommon in many parts of the world. The medical provider treating penetrating and explosive trauma in the austere environment is faced with multiple challenges to include: lack of medical supplies, prolonged evacuation time and distance, and lack of sophisticated care that is the standard for trauma care in the urban environment. This chapter will discuss the evaluation and treatment for penetrating and explosive injuries in the tactical environment.


Physics and Epidemiology


Ballistics

The available energy for a missile to inflict upon the body is dependent on the equation E = 1/2MV2, where M is the mass of the bullet (larger bullets impart more energy), and V is the velocity of the bullet as it hits the tissue. Thus, in most cases, the potential damage is greatest with a high-velocity round, such as that seen with a modern assault rifles and high-velocity hunting weapons.

For missile injuries, there are two areas of projectiletissue interaction. The first is a permanent cavity, which is a localized area of necrotic tissue and clot, proportional to the size of the projectile as it passes through. The second is a temporary cavity (cavitation) caused by the displacement of tissue away from the passage of the projectile. This
results in an area of contusion and concussion some distance from the actual path of the bullet. The amount of damage done to tissue depends on the amount of energy transferred to the tissue as well as the elastic properties of the tissue itself. Elastic tissues, such as skeletal muscle, blood vessels, and skin, may be displaced significantly due to cavitation but then rebound with minimal permanent injury. Inelastic tissue, such as bone, brain or liver, handles cavitation poorly and tends to fracture resulting in significant damage. There is also a shock (sonic) wave that also passes through tissue and does not cause any appreciable clinical effect (1,2).

Despite the fact that the energy can be imparted to a tissue is potentially most dependent on V2 the commonly held belief that high-velocity rounds always cause increased tissue damage is incorrect. Velocity is one factor in wounding. An increase in velocity does not de facto increase the amount of tissue damage. High-velocity rounds, if they do not impact bone or relatively inelastic tissues, such as brain or solid organs (liver), shatter or yaw in the tissue they may pass through the body, imparting little destructive energy (3). For example, the amount of tissue damage in the first 12 cm of a M-16A1 bullet wound has relatively little soft tissue disruption, similar to that of a 0.22 caliber long rifle bullet, which has less than half the velocity (4). Although the human thigh is approximately 12 cm wide in the average individual, it can be seen that a high-velocity round may pass through the body before it imparts any significant energy outside of the bullet path.

It has been suggested that high-velocity bullets will yaw in the tissue, increasing damage. Projectiles yaw in flight, which can create irregular wounds; however, unless a projectile hits an intermediate target, the amount of yaw in flight is insignificant. Yaw, in tissue, is in fact also seldom a consideration, as the bullets will not yaw until it penetrates deeply into the body. The AK-47 bullet, for example, yaws, but not until it has penetrated 25 cm into tissue (thus, in most cases, the bullet has already passed through the body before it has reached a depth sufficient to yaw) (5). The AK-74 assault rifle round, however, does yaw relatively early (about 7 cm of penetration), which may cause increased tissue damage.

Fragmentation of a bullet will also lead to increased tissue damage. The bullet fragments deviate out of the original bullet path in a multitude of directions and velocities causing damage to all the tissue they pass through. Although full metal jacket military rounds, in accordance with the Hauge agreement of 1899, are designed to remain intact in the body and many will, in fact, fragment after a certain distance in tissue. For example, the M-193 bullet of the M-16A1 rifle reliably fragments after traversing about 12 cm of soft tissue (6). Thus, again the bullet may have passed through the body before it fragments or if it enters tissue >12 cm in depth, it may cause significant damage due to multiple fragments formed. Military rounds and assault rifles are designed to wound (although often severely) rather than kill, because wounded individuals require greater resources to evacuate and care for than those killed outright (7).

It has been often stated that exit wounds are always greater than entrance wounds. This has been shown to be frequently not the case and has no bearing on care, which is always in response to the wound regardless of whether it is an entrance or exit wound (8).


Explosive

An explosion is caused by the rapid chemical conversion of a liquid or solid material into a gas with a resultant kinetic energy release. Low-kinetic explosives (gunpowder) release energy slowly by a process called deflagration. In contrast, high-kinetic explosive detonation involves the almost instantaneous transformation of the physical space occupied by the original solid or liquid material into gases, filling the same volume within a few microseconds, and is, therefore, under extremely high pressure (Fig. 10.1). The highly pressurized gasses expand rapidly and compress the surrounding environment, generating a pressure pulse, which is propagated as a blast wave. This blast wave is called overpressure or blast wind. As a blast wave passes through the body, it causes damage by several different mechanisms. Patients injured from explosions usually suffer from a combination of blast, blunt, penetrating, and burn trauma (Table 10.1).

Propagation of overpressure waves down range is dependent on the environment. There are several related phenomena of a blast waves that can cause considerably more damage to the victim. Coupling occurs when one blast wave converges with another or multiple waves. The waves are additive in their destructive nature to the tissue. Reflected waves occur when the explosive force reflects off of a structures or surfaces. Both of these types of waves usually occur together in closed spaces such as buses, buildings, or streets between buildings. The cumulative force exerted on the body from reflected and coupled wave’s increases the risk of primary blast injuries. The caregiver has to have a high clinic index of suspicion when evaluating these patients exposed to such situations.

Tympanic membrane (TM) rupture is a good marker for significant exposure to blast waves. The average kinetics necessary to incur such an injury can also cause occult or delayed primary blast injuries. When a ruptured,
TM is seen in a patient exposed to explosive forces, a thorough evaluation needs to be performed even in the absence of significant injuries. Delayed presentations of occult bowel wall, pulmonary, and neurological injuries are common. Observation and repeated assessment needs to be performed for approximately 24 hours as most occult injuries will be recognized during this time.






FIGURE 10.1. Explosive injury forces.








TABLE 10.1. Categories of Explosive Injuries.

























Category


Mechanism


Injury Type


Primary


A form of barotrauma, unique to explosions, which causes damage to air-filled organs.


▪ Blast lung


▪ TM rupture and middle ear damage


▪ Abdominal hemorrhage and perforation


▪ Globe (eye) rupture


▪ Concussion


Secondary


Penetrating trauma caused by the acceleration of shrapnel and other debris by the blast.


▪ Penetrating ballistic (fragmentation)


▪ Blunt injuries


▪ Eye penetration


Tertiary


Casualty becomes a missile and is propelled through the air, with typical patterns of blunt trauma.


▪ Fracture and traumatic amputation


▪ Blunt chest and abdominal trauma


▪ Impalement


▪ Closed and open brain injury


Quaternary


All other explosion-related injuries, illnesses, or diseases that are not due to primary, secondary, or tertiary mechanisms.


▪ Burns (flash, partial, and full thickness)


▪ Crush injuries


▪ Exacerbation of underlying conditions (i.e., Asthma, COPD, angina)


▪ Inhalation injury


TM, tympanic membrane; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.



Weapon Types

Low-velocity weapons: (<2,000 feet/sec and typically <1,100 feet/sec) do not as a general rule cause significant cavitation and have less propensity to cause significant soft tissue damage. Almost all civilian handguns are prime examples; these cause the majority of urban penetrating injuries.

High-velocity weapons: (>2,000 feet/sec) have the potential to cause significant soft tissue damage due to cavitation and include the M-16, M-4 carbine, AK-47, and AK-74 assault rifles. High-velocity civilian hunting rifles have a propensity to cause the most significant tissue damage. They fire large bullets at high velocity and the bullets are not metal jacketed, so they fragment quickly and yaw quickly. These bullets are designed specifically to impart massive tissue damage early (9). Unjacketed bullets in fact can cause a wound cavity up to 40 times the size of a jacketed bullet (10).


Explosive Devices

Because of the current increased terrorist threat and occurrence in many countries, multiple different explosive devices can be purposefully or accidentally encountered by adventure seekers even outside of previous “war” zones. Most accidental explosive injuries occur from handling or encountering mines, improvised explosive devices (IEDs), unexploded ordnance (UXO), such as grenades, and ammunition. In Afghanistan alone, the death and injury rate was 150 to 300 per month from accidental UXO encounters even before the current war.

An IED is often difficult to detect because it is made up of common items and can consist of almost any type of material and initiator. It is a “homemade” device that causes injury or death by using explosives alone or in combination with toxic chemicals, biological toxins, or radiological material. IEDs can utilize commercial or military grade explosives, homemade explosives, or military ordnance and can be found in varying sizes, functioning methods, containers, and delivery methods.


Commonly Encountered Assault Weapons

The AK-47 rifle is probably the most common weapon seen throughout the world. When firing the standard full metal jacketed bullet, there is a 25 cm path of relatively minimal tissue disruption before the projectile begins to yaw. This is why relatively minimal tissue disruption may be seen with some wounds. The AK-74 rifle utilizes a smaller 5.45-mm round compared to the AK-47. As previously mentioned, the AK-74 round tends to yaw early at 7 cm; therefore, it is more likely to cause increased tissue damage.

The M-16A1 and M-4 carbine fire a 55-grain full metal jacketed bullet (M-193) at approximately 950 m/sec. The full metal jacketed bullet penetrates about 12 cm before it yaws to about 90 degrees, flattens, and then breaks at the
cannalure (a groove placed around the midsection of the bullet) (4) (Fig. 10.2).






FIGURE 10.2. Standard full metal jacket military rounds found commonly throughout the world.

There are many types of bullets now being used in weapons, such as incendiary rounds, designed to set fire to whatever they hit. Hollow point or “dum dum” bullets are designed to flatten when they hit tissue and, thus, increase tissue damage earlier upon striking the target and not penetrate objects. Armor piercing rounds designed to penetrate the light armor of vehicles. Clinically, this myriad of rounds will cause lesser or greater tissue damage, and there is nothing relevant for wound care based solely on what type of round was fired (11).

In summation, the most important determinant of tissue damage is the amount of energy transferred to the tissue rather than whether the wound is caused by a highor low-velocity injury. A high-velocity weapon may pass through the body imparting little energy to the tissues and, thus, result in a wound similar to a low-energy transfer wound. The depth to which a bullet penetrates can affect the severity of the injury; wounds that penetrate to great depth without exiting the body will yaw and fragment imparting significant damage to the tissues. Bullet fragments that hit bone can result in significant tissue damage as well as the creation of secondary missiles and trauma. Each wound must be approached individually. Those that cause massive tissue injury require more extensive debridement regardless of being caused by high- or low-velocity projectiles.


Shotgun Wounds

Shotguns at close range are among the most destructive of all weapons as they disperse all of their energy into the affected tissue within a short distance. Shotgun wounds sustained at short ranges (<3 m) can be particularly devastating with massive tissue destruction, and the shotgun wadding also penetrates the wound leading to soft tissue contamination and bacterial proliferation (12). In contrast, however, shotguns wounds sustained at a distance may cause minimal injury (13

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 4, 2016 | Posted by in EMERGENCY MEDICINE | Comments Off on Penetrating and Explosive Injury Patterns

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access