Medical Implications and Planning for Riots and Mass Gatherings



Medical Implications and Planning for Riots and Mass Gatherings


Faith A. Dillard

Carl Menckhoff



OBJECTIVES

After reading this section, the reader will be able to:



  • As a tactical emergency medical services (TEMS) provider, describe the variables involved in preparing the medical care for a mass gathering


  • Describe the steps needed to plan for and implement medical care at a mass gathering


  • Discuss the special factors associated with different types of events


  • Discuss the world literature on mass gatherings

Mass gatherings are defined as planned events with large numbers of individuals gathered together in a specific area for a specific purpose. The number of people gathered may vary greatly, and although a mass gathering is classically defined as more than 1,000 people (1, 2, 3 and 4), the vast majority of mass gathering events far exceed this number.

In the United States alone, 165 million people attend NBA, NFL, and NCAA events every year (5,6), and with our ever-shrinking world we must now take into account a global perspective, in which we understand not only the epidemiology of an individual locality, but that of travelers and current worldwide health issues.

This chapter describes the myriad of factors that must be taken into account when planning and implementing medical care for a mass gathering and provides a step-by-step approach and timeline for setting up care for a future event. While the TEMS provider may not be directly involved with the medical planning for a mass gathering event, it is important to understand the principals involved and to be able to interface with the medical system that is in place for the mass gathering event.


Historical Perspective

The gathering of a large number of people together presents unique challenges for medical support, both logistically ands with regard to the wide variety of potential medical problems. For example, the density of the
population at these events lends itself to the possibility of high numbers of victims in the event of a terrorist event as well as logistic difficulties in terms of triage, treatment, and transport. It is therefore important to have a well-prepared plan for all contingencies.

Since the dawn of history humans have gathered for pilgrimages, and fled en masse from famines, floods, and oppression in large numbers. Some of the earliest recorded include the biblical journey of Moses and the Israelites across the Egyptian desert and the first pilgrimage to Mecca in 628 AD, as Mohammed led 1,400 followers on the first Hajj (7). The Hajj has become the largest mass gathering in the world, with up to 4 million worshippers traveling to Mecca each year (8).


EVENT PLANNING


Event Planning Committee

The first step in the medical preparation for an event is to define and assemble the event planning committee. For a major event, this should occur at least a year prior to the event date (Table 31.1) and consist of the event coordinator, the medical director, EMS, venue public safety/security, fire protection, and law enforcement. The TEMS provider should take part in this planning process when possible. This early coordination is important for an effective response between the TEMS unit and the event medical staff. Having a good understanding of the Incident Command System (ICS) and having the event integrated into the local ICS is essential for mass gathering planning.








TABLE 31.1. Timeline for Preparation.
















































































































































Timeline


12 mo


10 mo


8 mo


6 mo


4 mo


3 mo


2 mo


1 mo


1 wk


1 d


Meet with event coordinator


X




X





X


X


Define scope of event


X


Assemble event planning committee


X


X


Meet with planning committee



X


X


Designate agency responsibilities


X




X



X



X


X


Visit venue


X




X





X


X


X


Develop map of venue



X



X


Designate medical director


X


Develop plan for medical coverage




X


X


Recruit volunteers


X


X


X


X


X


X


X


X


X


Secure liability insurance





X


Order uniforms/shirts






X


Acquire communication system





X


Test communication equipment





X






X


X


Acquire medical equipment & supplies




X


X


X


X


X


X


X


X


Set up for event










X


X


Adapted from Menckhoff CR, Shaw M. Mass gathering preparedness. In: Keyes DC, Burnstein JL, et al., eds. Medical Response to Terrorism. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, 2005:257-268, and Wetterhall SF, Coulombier DM, Herndon JM, et al. Medical care delivery at the 1996 Olympic Games. JAMA. 1998; 279(18):1463-1468.


The event coordinator is responsible for coordinating the entire event (of which medical care is one part) and is often the key person in terms of logistical and financial support. The medical director is responsible for coordinating all aspects of medical care for the event, from triage and on-site first aid, to stabilization and transportation, to disaster planning. It is also the responsibility of the medical director to make sure that whatever plan is developed can be smoothly integrated into existing plans of EMS/fire/law enforcement/secret service or any other agency’s preexisting plan. EMS plays a vital role in most mass gatherings and should be included in the planning for medical care from the start. While the traditional role of EMS is certainly useful, there are several studies (9, 10 and 11) showing that protocols can be devised to expand their usual scope of practice to include a number of different treat and release scenarios. The roles of venue security and local law enforcement (including the TEMS team) need to be clearly defined. Crowd control, access to and egress from the event site, and the response to a terrorist incident are areas where they will have the lead role. How transfer of care occurs between the TEMS team and the event medicine team should also be addressed. The local fire service can supply information regarding the planned response to the event and should be made aware of any chemicals, pyrotechnics, or other fire hazards caused by the event (12). Many states, counties, municipalities, and local governments also have plans and legislation concerning mass gatherings. In planning for any event, these local and state guidelines should be sought out and integrated. In the event of a mass casualty incident (MCI), the roles of all of the various agencies involved need to be determined, with the medical director
negotiating a position within the command center. Local disaster preparedness plans may assist in planning and preparing for a mass gathering event, and some localities may request assistance from the Federal Disaster Medical Assistance Teams (DMAT) in their area. DMAT teams are often willing to participate, as the event also acts as training for their team.


Event Profiling

Profiling of the event itself is vital in planning for the necessary medical care. There is a myriad of variables that affect the volume of patients as well as the types of medical problems likely to be encountered. These, in turn, define the amount and type of staffing that will be needed.


Event Type

Certain types of events can be predicted to have a higher volume of patients. From a review of the literature over the last 35 years it is clear that an increase in the use of alcohol and drugs has a direct correlation with patient volume (5,13, 14, 15 and 16). It follows that events where this is more prevalent (primarily rock festivals, rock concerts, and raves) will have a higher medical usage rate (MUR). In one study of an outdoor venue hosting multiple events over a 5-year period, it was found that rock concerts had a 2.5 times increase in MURs over nonrock concerts (17).

Event type can also help predict injury type and severity. While the vast majority of patient encounters at any event are for minor complaints (18, 19 and 20), some (usually high-kinetic energy) events have the potential for more severe injuries. In 1988, at an air show in Ramstein, Germany, an airplane fell into a patient enclosure, killing 45 and injuring more than 500 (21). Also in 1988, at the Three Rivers regatta, a formula 1 boat collided with the shore, injuring 24 spectators (22). At a rock concert in Washington, DC, in 1999 (23), the MUR was 82.9 patients per 10,000 people in attendance (PPTT), with injuries from mosh pits accounting for 37% of the encounters.


Weather

Changes in weather can greatly affect the number and types of patient encounters. In general, one should consider that extremes in temperature (especially heat) can lead to higher usage rate (5,24, 25, 26 and 27). At a 7-day AIDS bicycle ride in California in 1996 (28), temperatures reached 107°F one day, with 70% of cases seen being related to heat. Another study (29) calculated that for every increase in the heat index (heat and humidity) by 10°F, there was an increase of 3 PPTT. At a rock concert in Woodstock, New York, in 1994, however, there was rain followed by a drop in temperature of 30°F, which led to markedly increased usage rates of 143 PPTT (30,31). Similarly at a papal visit in Colorado in 1993, temperatures dropped from 89°F during the day to 56°F at night and spectators who had been cooled with hoses during the day were shivering at night (32,33).

Jun 4, 2016 | Posted by in EMERGENCY MEDICINE | Comments Off on Medical Implications and Planning for Riots and Mass Gatherings

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access